SEZ units are not exempt from compensation cess under GST

By -

The Honourable Andhra Pradesh High Court in a very important decision has held that no exemption from payment of compensation cess under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) is available on import of goods by units in Special Economic Zones (SEZs).


The judgement was delivered in the case of M/s.Maithan Alloys which was engaged in the business of manufacturing ferro alloys and was established as an SEZ unit

The high court in the above case observed that Sections 7, 26 and 50 of the SEZ Act, 2005, are the three main provisions which allow the SEZ units to claim the exemptions of duties, tax, cess and certain drawbacks and concessions.

The SEZ Act is a self-contained law that provides exemptions from various taxes and duties, including those on goods imported and exported by developers and units in SEZs. 

Therefore, the exemptions have to be looked into from the provisions of the said Act and not from elsewhere.

The key requirement for Section 7 to apply is that the law which imposes the tax, duty, or cess must be referenced in the First Schedule of SEZ Act 2005. 

Goods and Services Tax (Compensation to States) Act, 2017 is not mentioned in the First Schedule.

The AP high court noted that there is difference between the terms ‘tax/duty’ and ‘cess’. 

On considering Section 26(1)(a) and 2(zd) of SEZ Act along with Section 2(15) of the Customs Act, it becomes clear that ‘duty of customs’ used in Section 26(1)(a) pertains only to duty of customs and not any cess much-less the GST Compensation cess. 

Further, there is no exemption provided for compensation cess either under Customs Act or GST Act.

Accordingly, the AP high court held that GST Compensation cess is not exempt on import of goods (the case under consideration dealt with import of coal) by an SEZ unit.

Well.......

The order is likely to have an adverse impact on imports by SEZ units and act as a trigger point for raising of GST demands. 

If a relaxation is required, the industry should represent the Government for a retrospective exemption from payment of GST compensation cess in case of import of goods by an SEZ unit.

Else, they are liable to pay the Compensation Cess.


R.SRIVATSAN

NACIN, Chennai

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Mismatches between GSTR 2A vs 3B- Things to be considered before you respond to GST Notices

By -
Image
  Among the discrepancies for which notices are issued by department, mismatches between GSTR 2A vs 3B tops it all. Objective of this blog is to highlight aspects that are relevant while responding to the GST Notices especially for FY 2017-18 & 2018-19. Deadline to issue the order under sec 73(10) for FY 2018-19 is 30th April 2024, thus department is rushing orders in their favor, if you fail to highlight appropriate aspects in your reply to notices issued under sec 73/74. Introduction and relevance of GSTR 2A:   The FORM GSTR 2A was not established with a defined purpose for financial years 2017-18 and 2018-19.  Provision in respect of limit of ITC on basis of GSTR-2A was introduced only on 9-10-2019, but system was not fully established for some time.   Hence, for the financial years 2017-18 and 2018-19, insistence of matching of GSTR-2A and Input Tax Credit availed by recipient was not legitimized.  Provisions applicable from 9-10-2019 till 1-1-2022:   The ITC availed by recipie
Read more

Financial credit note as a conduit to transfer input tax credit- AAR AP

By -
Image
Background: The Applicant is engaged in business of supply various electronic items.  The supplier has issued Tax Invoice , and charged GST on such taxable value, calculated in terms of Section 15 of CGST Act, 2017.  The applicant submits that, supplier paid GST and filed GSTR-3B for the relevant tax period and reported details of supplies GSTR-1.  Applicant has received the goods and made the payment of consideration as per tax invoice for the goods received from the supplier.  The applicant has received various incentives viz. Turnover Discount, Quantity Discount, Cash Discounts, Additional Scheme Discounts, 3 Months regular scheme discounts, etc.  All the above discounts are in the form of after sale discounts. For the above-mentioned discounts, the supplier has raised financial/ commercial credit note without GST for accounting purpose only.  Further, supplier does not reduce its output tax liability in respect to said Financial/commercial Credit Notes, as Section 15 doesn't pe
Read more

Treatment of Wellness centres vs Hotel accommodation services under GST

By -
Image
Are Wellness centres Clinical establishment or Hotel accommodation services ? Recently, the Appellate Authority for Advance Rulings (AAAR), Uttarakhand state, in the case of Corbett Nature Reserve, held that its naturopathy center cannot claim GST exemption.  The AAAR upheld the ruling given by the Authority for Advance Ruling.  In this case, the applicant had submitted that the health care services provided by an independent unit within the resort – viz: Aahana Naturopathy Center is a clinical establishment, which offers nature cure and yoga therapies.  It has an authorised medical practitioner on its rolls and the facilities offered by this unit are available not just to in-house customers but are open to all. The Center is registered under the Clinical Establishment Act, 2010. Based on these facts, it contended that it qualified as a clinical establishment and should be eligible for exemption as a ‘health care services’ supplier as per Entry 74 of Notification 12/2017.  However, the
Read more